Unique Thanksgiving Dinner Ideas | Non Traditional Recipes and Fun! (2024)

~ From non-traditional Thanksgiving recipes to completely unique Thanksgiving dinner ideas (check out our “adventure” list near the end of this post!), we’ve got some fresh suggestions for celebrating Thanksgiving 2020. No disappointments – just a creative spin on joy. ~

Things May Be a Little Different This Year … How Can We Make That Feel OK?

For many of us this year, Thanksgiving is going to look a little different. Or, well, maybe A LOT different.

There are some seriously terrific ideas circulating out there right now, for celebrating Thanksgiving virtually (like planning a virtual family activity like a pie-making party – how fun)!

But I’ve been thinking specifically about the food traditions.

How Do We Re-imagine Thanksgiving Dinner?

One suggestion that I’ve personally been clinging to is the idea that, maybe instead of trying to force this year’s feast into being a traditional party, exactly the same as always (when it just won’tbe the same at all), it could be a great year to try something TOTALLY new.

No disappointment that 2020’s celebration wasn’t just like in years past, because you MEANT it to be something different.

Go “Off-Script” Rogue

I’m not sure yet if that strategy will work, but it somehow rings true to me.

Maybe that’s because, instead of feeling powerless and unable to create the Thanksgiving celebration we always do, it empowers us to think outside the box and re-imagine ways to be thankful.

It puts the ball back in our court to call some shots, which is something we haven’t had a lot of this year.

When it comes to the food for the feast, that could mean going completely off-script with a chili cook-off or seafood feast (I mean, hey, why not?) … or it might just mean trying some new recipes, instead of the usual standbys. (Probably easier, quicker, more stress-free ones! Because if there’s one thing we surely don’t need more of this year, it’s STRESS!)

Whatever it might mean for you and your family, I wanted to offer a few additional creative ideas for celebrating uniquely, and re-imagining 2020’s Thanksgiving feast, complete (of course!) with some of our favorite Thanksgiving recipes for you to try.

Just a little fun inspiration as you put together your ideas and menu …

Celebrate ALLLL Day Long (Starting with Breakfast … and Maybe Parade Bingo!)

In “normal” years, the big Thanksgiving dinner tends to be the focus of the entire day for most families.

One fun way to switch things up this year might be to feature some special Thanksgiving-ish foods all throughout the day, starting with breakfast. Flip on the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade (in its 2020 TV-only format), maybe play some Parade Bingo,and cozy in for a relaxed morning.

Or, turn Thanksgiving on its head entirely with an “upside down” Thanksgiving feast – by hosting the big meal of the day at breakfast this year (instead of waiting for a late-day turkey dinner to celebrate).

Wait … whaaaaaat????

Why not? This kind of Dr.-Seussy, topsy-turvy day can be especially compelling for younger kiddos, who love a little wackiness and happily embrace completely off-the-wall ideas with a sense of adventure (instead of with that feeling so many of us grown-ups have, of kinda being cheated a little).

You could go with some sort of traditional recipe, full of pumpkin flavors, like:

  • 10-Minute Pumpkin Pie Oatmeal (pictured above)
  • Healthy Pumpkin-Chocolate Chip Muffins
  • Healthy Pumpkin Bread Recipes

Or, you could conjure up a little creative fun with:

  • a make-it-your-way Waffle Bar (pictured above)
  • DIY Yogurt Parfaits
  • or by making wacky Pancake Shapes (and, if your kiddos are old enough, letting them try to make some creative shapes of their own, too!) Total bonus points if you can actually shape your pancakes into turkeys lol! 😉

Or, if you’d like to make breakfast the night before (so you can focus on getting all competitive with that Parade Bingo), try:

  • Farmers’ Market Overnight Breakfast Egg Casserole
  • Stuffed French Toast Breakfast Casserole
  • Mini Crustless Quiche Cups

Thanksgiving Snacks and Appetizers (And Maybe a Unique Movie Night??)

Here’s another off-script idea: If you can’t host your typical gathering, why not stage a game night or movie-thon with your immediate circle? Watch some feel-good flicks, and whip up some quick and easy “Thanksgiving-y” appetizers instead of a full holiday supper.

One way to make your movie night really unique is to ditch the Hollywood blockbusters in favor of family home movies. Kiddos love seeing movies of themselves when they were little.

And, since all of us are probably going to be missing relatives we can’t see this year, home movies are one way to bring those loved ones a little closer.

More {Memorable!} Bonus Points:

To take that movie night idea one step further, you could ask each part of your extended family – or your extended friend circle – to shoot a quick little movie on their phones and send it off to everyone else in the group. Maybe everyone shares a favorite memory of Thanksgivings past, or shares something they’re thankful for, or even lightens the mood with an upbeat greeting and “virtual hug.” Whatever you choose – save them up (no peeking!) for your Thanksgiving movie night!

Oh … and about those movie snacks. Of course, as always, you can also make these great munchies to keep hungry people happy while you finish cooking a big supper, if you’re still planning to wrestle a turkey this year!

  • 5-Minute Savory Pumpkin Hummus with Fresh Sage (pictured above)
  • Cranberry and Goat Cheese Crostini (or Dip)
  • Pumpkin Pie Spiced Candied Pecans
  • Sweet and Spicy Cream Cheese Dip

Creating a “Traditional Feast” with New Favorites

So, maybe you still want to do a rather traditional feast, but you like the idea of venturing into some new recipes, to make things feel intentionally a little edgy, a little unique and fresh. Or, maybe your typical menu just doesn’t work for 2020, if you’re cooking for a lot fewer people. Or … maybe you find yourself cooking the entire meal all by yourself, for the first year ever.

Not to worry!

If you’d still like to cook up a Thanksgiving dinner with a traditional vibe, but some new recipes, you’ve come to exactly the right place!

Because, you know, here at THK, we focus on bringing you recipes that are quick and easy. And (bonus for health-conscious 2020), they’re healthier, too!

Here are some great ideas:

Thanksgiving Salads

  • Adorable “Tom Turkey” Thanksgiving Salad (pictured above)
  • “Thanksgiving Salad” with Goat Cheese, Pears, Candied Pecans and Maple-Balsamic Dressing
  • Superfoods Brussels Sprout Salad
  • Spinach Salad with Apple, Cheddar and Smoked Almonds
  • Grape Salad with Cream Cheese-Vanilla Dressing

Thanksgiving Sides

  • Roasted Green Beans with Balsamic-Browned Butter
  • Easy Cranberry Sauce with Apples, Pecans and Pineapple (5 Minutes and No Cooking!)
  • Family Favorite Instant Pot Sweet Potato Soup
  • Roasted Root Vegetables with Honey-Dijon Drizzle
  • Easy Rosemary Roasted Potatoes
  • Blistered Green Beans
  • Microwave Spaghetti Squash with Sage-Browned Butter and Toasted Walnuts
  • Or … check out this list of even MORE (as in … more than 50 MORE!) Thanksgiving side dishes (pictured below)

Thanksgiving Desserts

It you wanna try something a little different from your usual pumpkin pie, how about:

  • 29 Unique and Easy Pumpkin Desserts
  • Or, for something even less traditional, try our refreshing Angel Food Cake recipe with winter fruit

And for the Ultimate Off-Script Adventure …

Ok. Here’s where it gets realllllly unique! Stick with me, friends … adventure awaits!

If you decide to completely jettison the turkey and stuffing this year, to thoroughly embrace the idea of making this year’s feast unique … consider a Thanksgiving dinner that brings your core family group together in the kitchen.

Choose a “participatory” meal idea, where everybody can play a role. This instantly gets people talking and interacting. And, instead of the focus being solely on the final Thanksgiving dinner table, with a meal that just doesn’t feel the same as always … the focus is on enjoying the creative process of dinner together!

Here’s what I mean:

Idea #1 – How about a make-your-own pizza bar, where everyone can roll out their own dough and choose their own toppings? (Our Mini Deep Dish Pizzas – pictured below – are a fun spin on this if you have kiddos.)

Idea #2 – Similarly interactive? A make-your-own taco bar! Set out taco beef and some of our Crock-Pot Chicken Tacos meat, and let everybody customize to their heart’s content. Nacho bars are fun and easy this way, too!

Idea #3 –Along those same lines are pasta bars, baked potato bars … anything your family likes to customize. They can all be fun ideas for this type of “make-your-own” night, too!

Idea #4 – Another “all-play” dinner concept is definitely fondue. It’s hard to feel sad and isolated and like Thanksgiving dinner is a weird disappointment when your core peeps are gathered around a melty, burbling pot of deliciousness, dipping and chatting and creating a unique moment of togetherness. (Pssssst … for a dipper-dessert treat, be sure to include our crazy-easy 3-Ingredient Chocolate Dip!)

Idea #5 – Get competitive (in a friendly-fun way)! At the beginning of this article, I mentioned a chili cook-off. You could use that concept as a springboard to host a family cooking competition, whether that’s an actual chili cook-off, or a Chopped-style game. The goal is fun, and a bright spot for your family in a uniquely challenging year.

Idea #6 – Eat the food you really want to eat! Whatever that might be – no rules! Remember that I also mentioned at the beginning of this article, that you could go for something like a seafood feast? Well, when I was a kid, we often had a couple of Thanksgiving dinners each year, with various family groupings. We didn’t need (or want) TWO turkey dinners, so one meal was always a seafood feast, which was pretty much the ultimate treat for my little family of four. You don’t have to do seafood, though – let yourself daydream over whatever your family would consider the ULTIMATE. You could even stage this as a cooking class, everybody working together to make a complicated recipe you’ve always wanted to try.

Whatever You Do …

Whatever you decide is right for your family this year, look for unexpected ways to make the unique feel special, instead of disappointing. To make it memorable for what you do have, not for what you missed.

Fingers crossed, next year we’ll be back to huge family gatherings, just like always.

Or, just maybe, we’ll all find a few new 2020 traditions, a few new-favorite recipes … that’ll become a part of future Thanksgivings, and make them even more special for the unexpected things 2020 brought into our lives.

Maybe. Just maybe.

I’m holding onto that hope.

Happy Thanksgiving … from all of us here at THK … to all of you!

You Might Also Like ...

19 Best Healthy Thanksgiving Vegetarian Main Dishes
17 Healthy Instant Pot Thanksgiving Recipes (That…
The Ultimate Turkey Salad Recipe (That Rescues…
Salad with Goat Cheese, Pears, Candied Pecans and…
Unique Thanksgiving Dinner Ideas | Non Traditional Recipes and Fun! (2024)

FAQs

What can I do instead of traditional Thanksgiving dinner? ›

25 Non-Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner Ideas
  • 01 of 25. Artichoke Hearts Gratin. ...
  • 02 of 25. Roasted Pumpkin Soup. ...
  • 03 of 25. Roasted Pumpkin and Goat Cheese Crostini. ...
  • 04 of 25. Apple Pie Shot. ...
  • 05 of 25. Citrus Turkey Brine. ...
  • 06 of 25. Bacon-Wrapped Pork Medallions. ...
  • 07 of 25. Tangy Honey-Glazed Ham. ...
  • 08 of 25.
Oct 3, 2023

How to switch up Thanksgiving dinner? ›

Think: pumpkin risotto, crab-stuffed mushrooms, sweet potato curry, and cauliflower gratin. Looking to skip the roasted turkey? No problem! Try a tender roast beef or an easy slow cooker pork chop recipe instead!

What is the least favorite dish for Thanksgiving? ›

The Most Interesting Discoveries:

Most people over 60 chose Green Bean Casserole as their most hated side dish. Those under 40 also disliked Green Bean Casserole, but they had equal distaste for Sweet Potato Casserole. These two “retro” or “vintage” recipes were the most disliked on the list.

How do you make Thanksgiving special without family? ›

What to Do on Thanksgiving Without Family
  1. Book a night at a local hotel. Anything you can do out of the ordinary will make the holiday feel special and not blah. ...
  2. Stay in your PJs all day. 0 Guilt. ...
  3. Don't make any plans. ...
  4. Play charades over Zoom. ...
  5. Help a neighbor. ...
  6. Spend the day writing letters. ...
  7. Friendsgiving, duh.
Nov 20, 2020

How do you make Thanksgiving different? ›

Ahead, we've compiled a list of our favorite modern Thanksgiving traditions—and not all are about food: You could kick off the day with a turkey trot (or, if you're like us, a Bloody Mary bar), host a post-dinner game night or movie marathon, take a group photo in matching, holiday-themed pajamas, make DIY place cards, ...

What are four commonly consumed foods at Thanksgiving other than turkey? ›

Cornish game hen, goose, duck, ham, beef, salmon, and mushroom recipes make worthy centerpieces for holiday meals.

How do you simplify Thanksgiving dinner? ›

Tips To Simplify Thanksgiving Entertaining
  1. Pick the menu early. Don't leave menu planning and shopping to the last minute. ...
  2. Brine your bird. Turkey is the centerpiece of the feast, so give it every opportunity to shine. ...
  3. Start prep work a few days before Thanksgiving. ...
  4. Serve batched co*cktails. ...
  5. Create simple centerpieces.
Nov 1, 2023

How do you spice up Thanksgiving? ›

While there's nothing wrong with the usual cinnamon, cloves, allspice, and nutmeg, some star anise, grated fresh ginger, cardamom, or five spice powder are just exotic enough but won't scare away more conservative eaters.

What is the number one side dish for Thanksgiving? ›

Mashed potatoes are a traditional Thanksgiving side dish for a reason, and we definitely look forward to serving up this delicious dish every November.

What is the unhealthiest Thanksgiving food? ›

Unhealthy: Stuffing

“Bacon, sausage, mince meat, giblets, and a variety of similar ingredients find their way into many a stuffing, which takes an already unhealthy dish — often topping 500 calories per serving, depending on the recipe — to an entirely new level of unhealthy,” she said.

What is the most popular alternative to turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

Cornish game hen, goose, duck, ham, beef, salmon, and mushroom recipes make worthy centerpieces for holiday meals. This is collaborative content from Food & Wine's team of experts, including staff, recipe developers, chefs, and contributors.

What to do on Thanksgiving if you don't celebrate? ›

Not celebrating Thanksgiving doesn't mean you can't have fun during the break. Whether it be trying new foods, going shopping, exploring your artistic side or studying, you can make Thanksgiving break memorable and productive even without the traditional experiences.

What can I celebrate other than Thanksgiving? ›

Below, you'll find ten Thanksgiving alternatives you can check out, from National Day Of Mourning protests to National Family Week.
  • National Day Of Mourning. ...
  • Unthanksgiving Day. ...
  • National Day of Listening. ...
  • Native American Heritage Month. ...
  • Restorative Justice Week. ...
  • National Family Week. ...
  • National Game & Puzzle Week.
Nov 18, 2017

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 6773

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.