40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (2024)

Squirrel, like many other types of small game, makes good eating. That is provided you have a good squirrel recipe handy.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (1)

***Spring 2020 update***

Since this crisis began, this post has seen nearly 100,000 hits. While I’m glad everyone’s excited about hunting if you’re really thinking squirrel meat is going to keep you fed after SHTF that may be a pipe dream. I’d suggest planning ahead and checking out these survival food kits instead.

Still, there’s nothing wrong with supplementing your pantry with a bit of tasty squirrel meat. If you’re curious about how to cook it, read on my friends…

****

For the most part, I love watching squirrels forage on our land. They’re out there trying to make a living just like anyone.

This past year their population exploded, likely due to the untimely demise of our young hunting cat. They’ve destroyed crops, woken us from a sound sleep with their calls and most recently torn into the walls of the house.

Enough is enough, time to work on squirrel population control. We eat what we hunt, which means it’s time to research squirrel recipes!

Squirrel is part of a robust small game hunting tradition in the US, and a great way to introduce kids to hunting. Even if you’re not hunting, small squirrel traps can be remarkably effective for the squirrels in your attic, or you can go old school and use a figure 4 deadfall trap.

For newbies, I’d highly recommend this super quiet air gun that’s incredibly inexpensive (though check your local restrictions, some places class it as a firearm, while others don’t). For a more passive method, this squirrel trap is by far the best we’ve tested.

If you know the right technique, it takes less than a minute to gut a squirrel. After that, most squirrel recipes require that you part up the squirrel into cuts, and here’s how to do that.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (2)

For the most part, any recipe that calls for a rabbit can be made with a squirrel. I find that squirrel meat is much more flavorful, likely because they’re getting more exercise than domestic rabbits.

Don’t forget to cook the organ meats, and if you’re ambitious, you can even render squirrel lard. Scroll to the end for my recipe for squirrel lard cookies…

Fried Squirrel Recipes

Frying squirrels helps retain moisture in the meat, and the frying oil adds richness to otherwise lean meat. Fried squirrel is often served with biscuits and gravy, and that’s how I make it.

Be careful, fried squirrel cooks very quickly. It’s really easy to overcook the meat and burn the breading, so watch it carefully as it cooks.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (4)

Buttermilk Fried Squirrel with Biscuits and Gravy

Squirrel Stew Recipes

Stewing works well for squirrel meat, as it’s flavorful but often a little tough. The small cuts make a full meal when mixed into a squirrel stew.

The fact that squirrel can be a bit dry doesn’t much matter in a squirrel stew, where the rich broth helps everything stay moist and tender.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (5)

Traditional Brunswick Stew

Squirrel Chilli Recipes

Chilli is one of those dishes that can handle just about any meat. Squirrel ads extra protein, and can be substituted into just about any meat-based chili recipe.

I like to slow cook the squirrel first, de-bone the meat and then add the meat to avoid any bones in the finished squirrel chili.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (6)

Our own version of squirrel and red wine chili

Slow Cooker Squirrel Recipes

Low and slow they say with game meats, and squirrel meat is no exception. I like to add a good bit of salt to the slow cooker, which helps squirrel meat stay moist during the cooking process.

Of course, you can make squirrel chili in the slow cooker, but there are other tasty options too…

Squirrel Pasta Recipes

Pasta is a base that works with just about anything, even squirrel. Though I haven’t made any squirrel pasta recipes yet, I’m particularly excited about making squirrel ravioli.

The meat, finely diced, will add flavor and protein to the ravioli while other fillings like ricotta will help add richness to help balance out lean squirrel meat.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (7)

Roasted and Grilled Squirrel Recipes

Admittedly, roasting and grilling lean meat like a squirrel is tricky. Food for hunters has some excellent advice on how to properly grill a squirrel (along with an epic recipe for Jamaican Jerk Squirrel):

“Grilling squirrel isn’t as tricky as most people think. If done incorrectly, it can dry out very easily, but the secret to grilling perfect squirrel is no secret at all. As with any lean, “tougher” meat, and squirrels would fall into this category, the trick is to remove as much silver skin as you can without sacrificing too much meat. Silverskin tightens up and becomes chewy when exposed to heat, and will make the rest of your squirrel meat tough. Of course, you can’t get it all, but get as much as you can– that white, cloudy or clear-looking film that covers the pink meat underneath.

The second rule is to marinate the squirrel for a few hours or overnight in something that has an acid, such as vinegar or citrus. The marinade will infuse into the meat to help keep it moist while on the grill, while the acid will help to tenderize and break down the meat. We chose a Jamaican “Jerk” marinade because it’s one of our favorites for the grill. Finally, grill squirrel directly over hot coals just until cooked through and no longer.

Don’t expect it to be as tender as farm-raised chicken. It’s a wild animal that spends most of its time running around, and if you know squirrels, you’ll know that they can’t keep still for long. Squirrel meat has a pleasant “snap” to it. Respect it.”

Braised Squirrel Recipes

Slow cooking squirrel helps tenderize the meat and is especially tasty with a flavorful braising liquid. The next squirrel we get, I’m making braised squirrel and pumpkin dumplings…

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (8)

Braised squirrel meat that has been deboned. This is the meat from one young grey squirrel.

Pressure Cooker Squirrel Recipes

They say you can cook anything in an instant pot, and squirrel is no exception! Whether it’s a new-fangled modern electric pressure cooker or an old-fashioned stovetop model, a pressure cooker is great at tenderizing the meat on older squirrels.

I’ve found 10-12 minutes in an instant pot works really well for the medium-sized grey squirrels we have around here, but I’ve seen many pressure cooker squirrel recipes that recommend 20-25 minutes. Those longer times are for really old tough squirrels or larger fox squirrels that just take more time to cook.

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (9)

Squirrel in an instant pot before cooking. We cooked this one on high pressure for about 11 min.

Squirrel Pot Pies, Hand Pies & Sandwiches

Pot pies have a rich creamy sauce that’s perfect for lean squirrel meat. Make it a pot pie for a hearty supper, or hand pie for a meal on the go.

Similarly, sandwiches are incredibly versatile and are often made with lean cuts of meat anyway. Substitute boneless squirrel meat for turkey, chicken or tuna in any sandwich recipe.

Squirrel Offal and Lard

If you’re going to go through the trouble of cooking squirrel, you might as well use the whole animal. Fried squirrel heart is a tender delicious morsel, and if you get several squirrels, an appetizer of fried squirrel hearts on crackers with cheese is a real show stopper.

Likewise, the liver makes good eating, and you can substitute squirrel liver in place of chicken livers in pate recipes. Or simply make a few bites of squirrel liver and onions.

The real prize though, believe it or not, is squirrel lard. Squirrels need to pack away plenty of fat to get through a winter, and if you harvest them in the late fall they have a surprising amount of fat.

Rendered squirrel fat is very neutral, with no gamey taste. Perfect for cookies…

  • How to Render Squirrel Fat (for cookies!)
  • How to Make Fatwax (animal fat salve with squirrel fat)

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (10)

Hazelnut cookies with squirrel lard

Squirrel Cookbooks

Beyond what’s listed here, there are plenty of wild game cookbooks that have fabulous squirrel recipes. A few decades ago squirrel meat was much more mainstream and squirrel recipes in generalized cookbooks were common.

My 1975 edition of Joy of Cooking contains several squirrel recipes (along with plenty of possum recipes too).

Other Wild Game Recipes

Looking for more wild game recipes? Here are a few to get you started:

  • How to Clean and Gut a Groundhog
  • Buttermilk Fried Groundhog
  • How to Cook a Deer Heart
  • Pemmican Lollipops for Your Bushcraft Sweetheart (with Deer Heart & Deer Lard)

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (11)

Related

40+ Squirrel Recipes for Small Game Hunters (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jonah Leffler

Last Updated:

Views: 6283

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jonah Leffler

Birthday: 1997-10-27

Address: 8987 Kieth Ports, Luettgenland, CT 54657-9808

Phone: +2611128251586

Job: Mining Supervisor

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Electronics, Amateur radio, Skiing, Cycling, Jogging, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Jonah Leffler, I am a determined, faithful, outstanding, inexpensive, cheerful, determined, smiling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.